What to look or in a VC ?

The recent news article about LPs getting increasingly disenchanted with their emerging markets portfolio is at odds with the bull run in the capital markets. I had talked about this in my earlier post - about the imminence of consolidation in the PE market in India. While this shake-out is going to inflict a lot of pain all across in the medium term, hopefully it would lead to sanity all around in the long term.

Getting back in line and continuing from the last post, I thought it best to do a critical self-appraisal of my brethren. So, what are some of the aspects an entrepreneur (or an investment banker) should look for in a VC during the limited interactions they have ?

• Understanding of business & appreciation: Is the VC giving you undivided attention during the meeting ? Does he/she come across as one who is willing to learn about your business and appreciate the finer aspects ? Can he understand the business beyond just numbers- CAGR, EPS and the like ?
  

• Communication: The same point I had outlined in last week's post holds true here. If he cannot pick up calls/respond to mails and convey decisions unequivocally and on time, how can he hold water for the long term ? What is the reputation of the person you are dealing with in the market ? Is he known to be not temperamental, rude and professional ?

• Relationship vibes and passion to build a business: Is this a guy you can get get comfortable with personally ? Will your team be comfortable interacting with him ? Is this person a shoulder you can cry on should times turn bad ? The easiest way to ascertain this is to look for anecdotal evidence from the VCs side of having added tangible value in their portfolio. A lot of inward looking entrepreneurs would rather have a passive financial partner than an activist, high-maintenance VC. The smart ones look beyond the pester (much like Socrates did with his wife Xanthippe) - "If I can tolerate her, I can attach myself to every human being else."

In summary, some of the best relationships are informal and between two level-headed people who have no qualms in disagreeing yet share a collective vision.

Regards
Varadha

varadha.r1@gmail.com
+91 9940670064

4 F's of Value Creation

Given a lot of Indian Entrepreneurs have a lot of fire anyway, I was wondering what differentiates the Suzlon's and the Infosys-es of the world from the also-rans. Here goes my thoughts :




Focus : I have seen the case of more than one excellent entrepreneur who tends to take his eye off the ball. Too often, there is another opportunity that comes along that for the right reasons, looks far more lucrative. Can you imagine a Sachin Tendulkar switching to football because he has achieved everything in sight ? Can you imagine Tiger Woods playing anything but golf even 20 years from now ?

Typical distractions are real estate, restaurants, schools etc. that also give you an added social tag. The focussed ones refuse to take the bait and instead improvise/innovate on their core business. The others inevitably regret it. The ones that successfully juggle different businesses are not the ones that micro manage, but find the right people to delegate to and manage by reviews and numbers.

Finesse: This is probably the most under rated quality that the most successful entrepreneurs possess. Too often, the ego, the past successes weigh heavily in the minds of entrepreneurs and force him/her to take a decision that may not necessarily be the best for everyone in the eco system. For eg., " I have dealt with unions before - let us shut this factory", "We need to do this acquisition at any cost " etc. The good ones know where to draw the line. They know how to treat their customers and employees well. That creates a virtuous cycle . More importantly, they know how to self-promote their company by touching the right wires in the eco system - case in point being Infosys whose PR machinery is always working overtime without necessarily giving that impression to the outside world. These become even more so important during critical occasions like an IPO, acquisition, investors' exit etc.

Flexibility: There is a thin line that differentiates Flexibility from Focus and the good ones seem to know it by magic. If the demand for your product is not as great as you would expect it to be, would you find the markets that can give you the demand ? Or would you tailor a new product that has a larger demand in the existing market ? Needless to say, there are no easy answers. The good ones take a periodic check on the business (both internally and externally) and often take calculated, mid - course corrections. For eg., who would have thought Steve Jobs would make success of iPod when it was released in 2001 ? A standalone music player in an era of convergence ? From a company known for its computers ?

Fast & Decisive: Someone famously said "A half executed idea is better than a paper vision". The good entrepreneurs move fast and decisively. Too often, I have seen issue like " We recruited him. He is not performing upto expectations. What do we do ? " persisting for a long time, board meeting after board meeting. Either you augment his skill sets with other people (sub-ordinates or peers) or get a better guy or help him to upgrade his skills.

Any thoughts, anyone ? Is there more to it ?

~Varadha
varadha.r1@gmail.com
+91 9940670064