J-Curve and the art of "Indian valuations"

Amidst the usual riff-raff of "Oh ! Dealflow has started thawing but so have valuation expectations, if so, even more", I thought it is best to discuss the concept of "Indian Valuations" since they always seem far removed from the rest of the world in terms of logic (or the lack of it). Ask anyone in the primary/secondary markets and they would tell you the same thing - India is always an expensive market when compared to the rest of the emerging markets as well.

In the PE world, more than ever, valuations seem to be dependent on ever increasing projections with an explosive growth budgeted for in the first 12-18 months post fund infusion and a steady 40-50% growth (?!) post that. However, IMHO, reality is far removed and completely counter-intuitive. Most companies I have seen have slow build-up of momentum and the torrent comes gushing out only after 2-3 years (what is known in technical parlance as the J-Curve). Why ?

• Transition of "Vision" and mindset: This is singularly the biggest roadblock to the immediate blossoming of an organization. Most often, PE deals take so long that promoters want to get into operations immediately thereafter and often a gush of liquidity is just the right medicine they need to go after the product/client/business they have always dreamt of. But what next ?
• Organizational build-up: Most entrepreneurs have always bootstrapped during their formative years - so MBAs and industry veterans were always given a pass because they cost too much. Even if fresh money has come in, it takes anywhere between 3-6 months to staff the key positions and another 3-6 months for the new recruits to be brought to speed to deliver.
• Market delays: Governmental clearances for the new land acquisition pending ? MoU submitted with vendors/customers yet to translate into commercials ? Temporary loss of demand for the product/service ? Undercutting by competitors ? You name it and it happens
• Business learning curve: Going after $ 5 mn contracts is not the same as going after $ 50 mn contracts. You may the right people but the smartest people still take time to understand nuances of what the customer wants and how the end product needs to be packaged/presented.
• Cultural/integration issues:In most cases, PE funds, being the "progressive animals" they are, induct fresh, young, smart talent who often come at better designations and higher salaries. This tends to cause a cultural rift within the organization with the old folk resenting this treatment. This leads to involuntary attrition/execution roadblocks within the organization.

As thumb rule, my experience has been that projections tend to be put off by one year in the best of teams and by 2-3 years at the other end. So, there goes the effect of J-Curve. Needless to say, the smarter PE funds have started baking it into their projections and have tended to adjust their valuations accordingly.


Regards
Varadha
(varadha.r1@gmail.com)
+91-9940670064